Ideals Make Us American, Not Origins

Nobody’s ever asked to see my birth certificate. But as someone of Chinese descent I have been asked plenty of times where I’m from — and when I say “Poughkeepsie,” I often get the follow-up question that’s almost a cliché now among Asian Americans: “No, where are you really from?”

It’s always disheartening to get that question, even though I’ve learned to answer it with equanimity and usually take care to make the inquisitor feel not-stupid. But it’s always clarifying, for it reveals the default picture in the minds of some of my fellow Americans about who they are, who we are, and who I am.

That’s why Mitt Romney’s birther-baiting remarks today are, in a way, welcome. Let there be no doubt: He is the candidate for people who think the name Obama must be Muslim and its bearer indelibly foreign. He is also the candidate for the greater number of people who do not initially imagine that someone with my face, my eyes, my skin could be from this country.

Read more.

1. nextinoffice likes this
2. trxfreely reblogged this from theatlantic and added:

   I’d say that I became, American more, long after I was born here.

3. kipanilove reblogged this from theatlantic
4. translatesarcastic likes this
5. circadianarrhythmia likes this
6. garytheduck2 likes this
7. artichokemug likes this
8. soul-snippet reblogged this from airportlife
9. bengal-indo reblogged this from theatlantic
10. dashboardpears reblogged this from theatlantic
11. leaveourexcellentsouls reblogged this from theatlantic and added:

    this (and it’s not just Asian Americans)

12. vwcg likes this
13. ky1980 reblogged this from theatlantic
14. ky1980 likes this
15. homecomingqueen reblogged this from theatlantic
16. perennialcalami reblogged this from airportlife
17. mytome reblogged this from airportlife
18. sinensiscamellia likes this
19. semper-fidelis-tyrannosaurus reblogged this from airportlife
20. nnyland likes this
21. airportlife likes this
22. candyrifle likes this
23. theysayimtall likes this
24. revolutionaryrebel reblogged this from theatlantic
25. thesecretnews reblogged this from theatlantic
26. aaygeecee likes this
27. theslattern reblogged this from theatlantic
28. lostbetweenthepages likes this
29. alejandriaa likes this
30. ajilivizion reblogged this from theatlantic
31. emturner likes this
32. crow332991 likes this
33. thejohnlucero reblogged this from theatlantic
34. milksheikh likes this
35. leknox reblogged this from theatlantic
36. lisztomanism reblogged this from theredshoes and added:

    this is one of the best opinion related stories I’ve ever read.

37. theredshoes reblogged this from theatlantic
38. theredshoes likes this
39. mikholas reblogged this from theatlantic
40. hillaryclintonsapprentice likes this
41. mgpettit likes this
42. butchrosser likes this
43. theendfantastic likes this
44. nattydefers reblogged this from theatlantic and added:

    lmao i love u mittens

45. mikiballard likes this
46. infinitewisdom likes this
47. dayalmohamed reblogged this from theatlantic
48. rodneyfromtexas likes this
49. graphitenpixels reblogged this from theatlantic
50. Show more notesLoading...