August 19, 2013
'Where Should I Go To College?'

Where should you go to college—assuming you’re a high school student and getting ready for this new phase of your life? Where should you encourage your son or daughter to go—assuming that you’re a parent? As a college professor, I get asked the where-to-go question frequently, and I know that all of us teaching in colleges and universities do too. How should one answer? What is the right thing to say to someone deciding on his or her future? For myself, I’m inclined to respond by posing another question.
Are you looking for a corporate city, or are you looking for a scholarly enclave? Neither of these kinds of schools exists in its pure form. To the scholarly enclave, even the most ideal, there will always be a practical, businessy dimension. Somebody’s got to keep the books and pay the bills. And even in the most corporate of colleges, there will be islands of relative scholarly idealism.
Many, if not most, American high school students have already had a taste of the corporate city. These are students and parents who are emerging from the mouth of that great American dragon called the “good high school.” I won’t hide my prejudices: I have a lot of qualms about the good American high school. Most good high schools now look to me like credential factories. They are production centers that kids check in to every day. The motivated, success- oriented students set to work from the moment of arrival, producing something, manufacturing something. And what they produce are credentials. High schools now are credential factories in overdrive.
Read more. [Image: Jonathan Ernst/Reuters]

'Where Should I Go To College?'

Where should you go to college—assuming you’re a high school student and getting ready for this new phase of your life? Where should you encourage your son or daughter to go—assuming that you’re a parent? As a college professor, I get asked the where-to-go question frequently, and I know that all of us teaching in colleges and universities do too. How should one answer? What is the right thing to say to someone deciding on his or her future? For myself, I’m inclined to respond by posing another question.

Are you looking for a corporate city, or are you looking for a scholarly enclave? Neither of these kinds of schools exists in its pure form. To the scholarly enclave, even the most ideal, there will always be a practical, businessy dimension. Somebody’s got to keep the books and pay the bills. And even in the most corporate of colleges, there will be islands of relative scholarly idealism.

Many, if not most, American high school students have already had a taste of the corporate city. These are students and parents who are emerging from the mouth of that great American dragon called the “good high school.” I won’t hide my prejudices: I have a lot of qualms about the good American high school. Most good high schools now look to me like credential factories. They are production centers that kids check in to every day. The motivated, success- oriented students set to work from the moment of arrival, producing something, manufacturing something. And what they produce are credentials. High schools now are credential factories in overdrive.

Read more. [Image: Jonathan Ernst/Reuters]

9:15pm
  
Filed under: Education College 
  1. kanobies reblogged this from theatlantic
  2. inspire2learn reblogged this from theatlantic
  3. futureenglishteacher93 reblogged this from withastartoguide
  4. withastartoguide reblogged this from lawrencepubliclibrary
  5. vanillaholmes reblogged this from lawrencepubliclibrary
  6. lawrencepubliclibrary reblogged this from theatlantic and added:
    Thinking about college? Check this out.
  7. draconicrose reblogged this from worldiary
  8. ronan-aodhan reblogged this from theatlantic
  9. thepandabaker reblogged this from maneatingbadger
  10. worldiary reblogged this from maneatingbadger
  11. maneatingbadger reblogged this from pol102
  12. thesecularsoup reblogged this from theatlantic
  13. thatpersonalblog reblogged this from theatlantic
  14. trueplayashit reblogged this from theatlantic
  15. true-antagonist reblogged this from englishmajorinrepair
  16. pag-asaharibon reblogged this from theatlantic
  17. kellyscadetportfolio reblogged this from theatlantic
  18. independentcause reblogged this from theatlantic
  19. thatgothlibrarian reblogged this from rewardingcuriosity
  20. sablesoull reblogged this from theatlantic
  21. audiohno reblogged this from theatlantic
  22. prolepticvison reblogged this from mountainpass
  23. mountainpass reblogged this from theatlantic
  24. fledermoyse reblogged this from teamanthro
  25. teamanthro reblogged this from theatlantic