September 11, 2013
The U.S. Has No Right to Spy on Masses of Regular People in Other Countries

I am not suggesting that the United States should abandon collecting foreign intelligence entirely. What I am suggesting is that certain kinds of international spying are morally permissible and legitimate, while other sorts are immoral and illegitimate. Drawing a coherent line is extremely difficult, and certainly beyond my abilities, but I can give examples of what I regard as clearly legitimate and what is clearly illegitimate. An example of spying to which I don’t object: intercepting intra-regime communications in Syria. An example of spying that strikes me as contrary to American ideals: dragnet spying on the private communications of every German citizen. The NSA was created in an era when technological limitations ensured that foreign spying would be directed, for the most part, at foreign governments. Now we have the ability to accumulate massive data on masses of individuals in liberal democracies.
We have no moral right to do so. Just as Britain’s intelligence agency has no moral right to break into my email account or to maintain a database with my Skype calls.
Read more. [Image: Mr. T in DC/Flickr]

The U.S. Has No Right to Spy on Masses of Regular People in Other Countries

I am not suggesting that the United States should abandon collecting foreign intelligence entirely. What I am suggesting is that certain kinds of international spying are morally permissible and legitimate, while other sorts are immoral and illegitimate. Drawing a coherent┬áline is extremely difficult, and certainly beyond my abilities, but I can give examples of what I regard as clearly legitimate and what is clearly illegitimate. An example of spying to which I don’t object: intercepting intra-regime communications in Syria. An example of spying that strikes me as contrary to American ideals: dragnet spying on the private communications of every German citizen. The NSA was created in an era when technological limitations ensured that foreign spying would be directed, for the most part, at foreign governments. Now we have the ability to accumulate massive data on masses of individuals in liberal democracies.

We have no moral right to do so. Just as Britain’s intelligence agency has no moral right to break into my email account or to maintain a database with my Skype calls.

Read more. [Image: Mr. T in DC/Flickr]

9:43am
  
Filed under: NSA Spying Civil liberties 
  1. stayclassyhitchcock reblogged this from theatlantic
  2. leftistshuffle reblogged this from theatlantic and added:
    The U.S. Has No Right to Spy on Masses of Regular People in Other Countries I am not suggesting that the United States...
  3. kinryuzan-raimon reblogged this from theatlantic
  4. niesenn reblogged this from theatlantic
  5. johnandfrank reblogged this from theatlantic
  6. consistentlyinconsistent3 reblogged this from writerwhocouldntwrite
  7. mohd1967 reblogged this from humanrightswatch
  8. 30minutefan reblogged this from theatlantic and added:
    AGREE OR DISAGREE?
  9. thetreasureseeker reblogged this from theatlantic
  10. lorpy reblogged this from humanrightswatch
  11. popolol reblogged this from inspirement
  12. mix-a-lot reblogged this from theatlantic
  13. stringsdafistmcgee reblogged this from theatlantic
  14. diamonds-onthesoles-ofher-shoes reblogged this from theatlantic
  15. ingsoc14 reblogged this from humanrightswatch
  16. theawkwardteenager50 reblogged this from humanrightswatch
  17. imonlymildlyinsane reblogged this from zombieapocalypseteam
  18. brashreasoning reblogged this from theatlantic
  19. thegrayprince reblogged this from themediafix
  20. kaliem reblogged this from humanrightswatch
  21. randycwhite reblogged this from theatlantic