February 20, 2014
The Incoherent Backlash to Black Actors Playing ‘White’ Superheroes

Michael B. Jordan has been cast as Johnny Storm in the new Fantastic Four movie. For many prospective viewers, that announcement will raise the question that any announcement of a Michael B. Jordan movie raises: Will he be shirtless, and for how much screen time? Other superhero fans, though, are distracted by less wholesome concerns. Johnny Storm, they have noticed, is white. Michael B. Jordan is black. How, they wonder, can this be?
The outcry over interracial casting here appears to be much more muted than the stir over Idris Elba’s role as Heimdall in the Thor franchise, which provoked boycott threats. Still, I’ve seen people on Twitter talking about how the casting will “ruin” the franchise. I’m not going to link because I’m leery of shaming people that way on a mainstream site, but if you look around you can find them without too much trouble. (Niki Cruz has rounded up some of the response, with names redacted, here.) This echoes earlier controversies in which a campaign to get Donald Glover cast as Spider-Man met with racially fraught backlash, while the casting of Amandla Stenberg as Rue in The Hunger Games provoked angry social media whining.
Read more. [Image: John Shearer / AP; Adi Granov / Marvel]

The Incoherent Backlash to Black Actors Playing ‘White’ Superheroes

Michael B. Jordan has been cast as Johnny Storm in the new Fantastic Four movie. For many prospective viewers, that announcement will raise the question that any announcement of a Michael B. Jordan movie raises: Will he be shirtless, and for how much screen time? Other superhero fans, though, are distracted by less wholesome concerns. Johnny Storm, they have noticed, is white. Michael B. Jordan is black. How, they wonder, can this be?

The outcry over interracial casting here appears to be much more muted than the stir over Idris Elba’s role as Heimdall in the Thor franchise, which provoked boycott threats. Still, I’ve seen people on Twitter talking about how the casting will “ruin” the franchise. I’m not going to link because I’m leery of shaming people that way on a mainstream site, but if you look around you can find them without too much trouble. (Niki Cruz has rounded up some of the response, with names redacted, here.) This echoes earlier controversies in which a campaign to get Donald Glover cast as Spider-Man met with racially fraught backlash, while the casting of Amandla Stenberg as Rue in The Hunger Games provoked angry social media whining.

Read more. [Image: John Shearer / AP; Adi Granov / Marvel]

  1. change--in-weather reblogged this from theatlantic and added:
    This dude is an amazing actor
  2. slip-tothevoid reblogged this from canfy
  3. art-nirvana reblogged this from theatlantic
  4. musingsofanobody reblogged this from kittykeoko
  5. shibuya-rin reblogged this from insatiable-wendigo
  6. kurazaibo reblogged this from kittykeoko
  7. kittykeoko reblogged this from insatiable-wendigo
  8. insatiable-wendigo reblogged this from purplemountainsmajesty420
  9. purplemountainsmajesty420 reblogged this from theatlantic
  10. scorpionkingcirca81 reblogged this from bigthanglong1
  11. shulamithbond reblogged this from bleeding-rust
  12. bleeding-rust reblogged this from theserpentunderneathh
  13. theserpentunderneathh reblogged this from theatlantic
  14. bigthanglong1 reblogged this from opheliathyme and added:
    Digg that
  15. thequestionwontcomeout reblogged this from boss-lady-lifter and added:
    ^^^^^^ They’re siblings- it’s not racist to say it makes no sense for him to be black
  16. cadosanctus reblogged this from inkyhumor
  17. inkyhumor reblogged this from theatlantic
  18. fibonacci-flowers reblogged this from alexriesart
  19. theramblingbramble reblogged this from sayyeahletsbealonetogether
  20. sayyeahletsbealonetogether reblogged this from theatlantic
  21. nusoulseeker reblogged this from latinegro
  22. shineepenguins reblogged this from jinkidubu
  23. luke-jaywalker reblogged this from alexriesart
  24. wickedgames3174 reblogged this from theatlantic
  25. thesedaysimfine reblogged this from ichbinyuki
  26. mickiebeau reblogged this from queerplatonic-kagakuro